War Is Hell, but What Is Homesteading?

Chip Kerr, the 49th, and a Victoria Cross at Courcelette

One wounded man. Sixty-two prisoners. A quarter-mile of enemy trench. Here’s how an Edmonton farmer pulled it off and why it was genius, not luck.

On 16 September 1916, on the Somme, Private John Chipman “Chip” Kerr of Edmonton’s 49th Battalion was clearing a German trench with a bombing party that was running out of grenades. So, with one of his fingers freshly blown off, he climbed out of the trench onto the parados, the most exposed ground on the battlefield, ran along the top above the enemy, and opened fire from behind them. Believing themselves surrounded, sixty-two Germans surrendered. It earned him the Victoria Cross.

In this episode, we rebuild the deed from the ground up: who Kerr really was (and what his attestation papers actually say), how the 49th was raised in Edmonton and then gutted at Mount Sorrel, how trench fighting and the hand grenade truly worked and why Kerr’s move wasn’t just brave, it was brilliant. Along the way, you’ll hear the voices of men who were there, and Kerr’s own grandson recounting the family story and the famous note left on a homestead door: “War is Hell, but what is homesteading?”

Heavy on tactics, rooted in the local Edmonton story, and grounded in the records, including a few myths we set straight along the way.

Much of the research behind this episode lives in the building that carries the 49th Battalion’s lineage: the Loyal Edmonton Regiment Military Museum, inside the historic Prince of Wales Armouries at 10440 – 108 Avenue NW in Edmonton. Walk through the Griesbach Gallery, stand in front of Cecil Kinross’s miniature Victoria Cross, and see everything we talked about today in the cases and on the walls. I’m currently doing my university practicum there, so if you’re in Edmonton, come and find me. Let’s talk history.

🌐 lermuseum.org

SOURCES & FURTHER READING

Primary sources

  • Kerr’s VC citationThe London Gazette, No. 29802, 26 October 1916. (Searchable free at the official Gazette: thegazette.co.uk)
  • Kinross’s VC citationThe London Gazette, No. 30471, 11 January 1918.
  • CEF attestation papers (Kerr brothers) — Library and Archives Canada, Personnel Records of the First World War (RG 150). Chip Kerr attested 25 Sept 1915 (reg. no. 101465); Charles Roland Kerr attested 22 Oct 1915; same approving officer on both. Free, digitized, downloadable as PDF: https://www.bac-lac.gc.ca/eng/discover/military-heritage/first-world-war/personnel-records/Pages/personnel-records.aspx
  • The Forty-Niner (49th Battalion Association magazine), July 1933 — states Kerr “was drafted to the 49th in June 1916” on the breaking-up of the 66th Battalion.
  • 49th Battalion operations account / war diary, 15–18 September 1916 — Library and Archives Canada (referenced in the LAC blog feature below).

Books & official histories

  • Tim Cook, At the Sharp End: Canadians Fighting the Great War, 1914–1916 (Vol. 1). — The Canadian Corps’ “learning curve,” the Somme, and the push toward initiative at the sharp end.
  • Col. G.W.L. Nicholson, Canadian Expeditionary Force, 1914–1919 — the Official History of the Canadian Army in the First World War. (Freely available as a PDF from the Government of Canada / Canadian military history collections.)

Museums & archives

Web references & background

  • The Canadian Encyclopedia — “Battle of Courcelette” and “Battle of Mount Sorrel.” https://www.thecanadianencyclopedia.ca
  • Vimy Foundation — the creeping barrage and Courcelette. https://www.vimyfoundation.ca
  • Canadian Great War Project — service summaries for Kerr and Kinross. https://canadiangreatwarproject.com
  • Canada’s Historic Places / Alberta Register of Historic Places — Prince of Wales Armouries (former Edmonton Drill Hall, opened Nov 1915) and the Victoria Armoury (former Land Titles Building, home of the 19th Alberta Dragoons). https://www.historicplaces.ca
  • RETROactive (Alberta’s Historic Places) — “Victoria Cross Mountain Ranges” (Mount Kerr, Mount Kinross).
  • National WWI Museum and Memorial — hand grenades and trench-clearing tactics. https://www.theworldwar.org
  • William F. Stewart, “Hand Grenades and the Decline of Infantry on the Somme” — on grenade-led trench fighting.
  • 1914–1918-Online: International Encyclopedia of the First World War — “Hand Grenade” / bombing-party organization. https://encyclopedia.1914-1918-online.net
  • Wikipedia (entry points, then chase the citations): John Chipman Kerr; Cecil John Kinross; 49th (Edmonton) Battalion; 66th Battalion (Edmonton Guards); 51st Battalion, CEF; Battle of Flers–Courcelette; Mills bomb; Stielhandgranate.

Audio credits:

  • Graham Kerr (grandson of John Chipman Kerr) — interview by Craig Ketchum, “Recounting John Chipman Kerr, Victoria Cross recipient 1916,” YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2DXViuxcoME
  • Stephen Westmann and Ernest Bryan — interview recordings from the Imperial War Museums Sound Archive, featured in IWM’s podcast Voices of the First World War, Episode 23: “First Day of the Somme.” © IWM.
  • Harry Routhier and Roy Henley — interviews from the Heroes Remember video collection, Veterans Affairs Canada.

Beyond Winged Warfare: Canadians in the Air 1914–1918

In August 1914, Canada went to war without an air force. Not a small one. Not a token one. None. The country that had pioneered powered flight in the British Empire sent its young men overseas to fly other people’s airplanes, in other people’s uniforms, for other people’s wars.

What happened next is one of the most extraordinary and least-told stories in Canadian military history.

This episode follows five Canadian airmen: Billy Bishop, the most decorated pilot in the British Empire whose most famous action may never have happened; Raymond Collishaw, who outscored almost everyone and came home almost unknown; William Barker, Canada’s most decorated serviceman of the entire war, now largely forgotten; Wop May, the rookie who accidentally became the last man the Red Baron ever chased; and Alan McLeod, eighteen years old, who climbed out onto the wing of a burning aircraft at five thousand feet and flew it home.

Along the way, you’ll hear the actual voices of men who were there: a 1969 CBC interview with Collishaw and two of his Black Flight pilots, and a 1989 oral history with Mack McGill, a workaday RFC pilot who flew the front at twenty thousand feet and remembered, seven decades later, that the engine was no good after a few hours.

SHOW NOTES / SOURCES

Primary recommended reading

  • Tim Cook, At the Sharp End: Canadians Fighting the Great War, 1914–1916, and Shock Troops: Canadians Fighting the Great War, 1917–1918 (Penguin Canada, 2007 and 2008). Cook’s two-volume Canadian Expeditionary Force history is essential for institutional and cultural context, including the place of airmen in the broader Canadian war effort.
  • G.W.L. Nicholson, Canadian Expeditionary Force, 1914–1919: The Official History of the Canadian Army in the First World War (Queen’s Printer, 1962). The official institutional history.
  • S.F. Wise, Canadian Airmen and the First World War: The Official History of the Royal Canadian Air Force, Volume I (University of Toronto Press, 1980). The definitive scholarly account of Canadian aviators in the RFC, RNAS, and RAF.

Primary sources used in this episode

  • W.A. Bishop, Winged Warfare (1918) — Bishop’s autobiography. (Now public-domain; freely available via Internet Archive.)
  • Bishop’s letter to Margaret Burden, summer 1917 — quoted in the Globe and Mail, “Billy’s Battle,” April 20, 2002.
  • William Fry, Air of Battle — memoir of the deputy flight leader who declined to accompany Bishop on the June 2, 1917 raid.
  • Wop May’s combat report, April 21, 1918 — 209 Squadron records, reproduced at wopmay.com (Wop May family archives).
  • Wop May’s address to the 12th Calgary Scout Troop, February 19, 1952 — transcript reproduced at wopmay.com.
  • Alan McLeod’s letters home — preserved by the McLeod family; quoted in RCAF “Portrait of Courage” feature, 2017, and in Library and Archives Canada material.
  • Reverend Dr. David Christie’s tribute to Alan McLeod, Manitoba Free Press, November 7, 1918.
  • Raymond Collishaw, Alfred Williams “Nick” Carter, and William Melville “Mel” Alexander, CBC-TV interview, 1969 — Collishaw (the squadron and Black Flight commander), Carter (A Flight commander), and Alexander (Black Flight pilot, Black Prince) reminiscing about the 10 Naval Squadron and the Black Flight era. Source for Carter’s first-person account of shooting down a German aircraft into the Ypres canal and retrieving a piece of the wreckage; source for Alexander’s first-person account of his kill in the July 6th, 1917 dogfight (the day of Collishaw’s six victories), including his “you don’t stick around after that to see what happens” line and the period photograph he holds on camera. Available via CBC Archives (cbc.ca/player/play/video/1.3627782).
  • “Mack” McGill (likely William W. McGill, RFC), interviewed by James Pope, 1989 — late-life oral history with a non-ace Canadian RFC pilot who flew the Sopwith Dolphin on the Western Front in 1918. Source for McGill’s first-person account of flying at 20,000 feet, the cold in the open cockpit, and the unreliability of the Dolphin’s geared Hispano-Suiza V8. From Chris Charland’s “Classic Interviews,” a James Tallimar project for TimeKeepers Canada. (youtube.com/watch?v=W3ouuITIh84)
  • William W. McGill (RFC) oral history, 1978 — extensive interview recorded by the University of Victoria with a Guelph-born RFC pilot describing his training pipeline (Long Branch, School of Military Aeronautics, Camp Mohawk, Deseronto, Camp Borden, Texas) and overseas service from February 1918. Almost certainly the same man as “Mack” McGill in the Pope interview. Available via University of Victoria Library.
  • Raymond Collishaw with R.V. Dodds, Air Command: A Fighter Pilot’s Story (William Kimber, 1973) — Collishaw’s own memoir, the source for the “fiercest and most harmless” quote and the “sad moment when my squadron had to strike the Royal Navy ensign.”
  • Victoria Cross citationsLondon Gazette, August 11, 1917 (Bishop); May 1, 1918 (McLeod); November 30, 1918 (Barker).
  • Roy Brown’s Bar to Distinguished Service Cross citationLondon Gazette, June 18, 1918.
  • Wop May’s Distinguished Flying Cross citationLondon Gazette, September 1918.
  • Raymond Collishaw’s Distinguished Flying Cross citationLondon Gazette, August 3, 1918.
  • Denny May tells the story of his father, Wilfred ‘Wop May, – who was chased by the Red Baron just before the legend was shot down. Video by Ed Kaiser, Edmonton Journal, Feb. 28 2018

On the Canadian Aviation Corps

  • History of the Royal Canadian Air Force (institutional history) — for the formation and dissolution of the CAC; the Burgess-Dunne biplane; the September 16, 1914 authorization, the October 1, 1914 delivery, and the May 1915 dissolution.

On Bishop

  • Brereton Greenhous, The Making of Billy Bishop (2002) — the skeptical case.
  • Peter Kilduff, Billy Bishop VC: Lone Wolf Hunter — the defensive case.
  • Philip Markham, “An Investigation of the Aerodrome Raid,” Over The Front, Fall 1995.
  • Paul Cowan, dir., The Kid Who Couldn’t Miss (NFB, 1982).

On Barker

  • Wayne Ralph, Barker VC: William Barker, Canada’s Most Decorated War Hero (1997).
  • Ted Barris, “The Making of Billy Barker,” Air Force Magazine, November–December 2017.

On May

  • Sheila Reid, Wings of a Hero: Canadian Pioneer Flying Ace Wilfrid Wop May (1997).
  • The Wop May Chronicles family archive (wopmay.com).

On Collishaw, Carter, and Alexander

  • Raymond Collishaw with R.V. Dodds, Air Command: A Fighter Pilot’s Story (William Kimber, 1973).
  • Mike Bechthold, “Raymond Collishaw,” The Canadian Encyclopedia (Historica Canada, 2008; revised 2019).
  • Legion Magazine, “The amazing aerial feats of ace Raymond Collishaw” (2025).
  • John Harris, Knights of the Air: Canadian Aces of World War I (1958) — source for the famous “giving” victories anecdote about Collishaw’s leadership of new pilots.
  • Calgary Aero Space Museum, Nick Carter file (PDF, archived).
  • Alfred Williams Carter Distinguished Service Cross citation — London Gazette, August 29, 1917 (for actions of 22 and 24 July 1917).
  • William Melville Alexander Distinguished Service Cross citation — London Gazette, September 14, 1917 (for actions of 16, 20, and 21 August 1917).
  • CBC-TV profile of Collishaw and the Black Flight, 1969 — featuring interviews with Collishaw, Carter, and Alexander.

On McLeod

  • Veterans Affairs Canada online biography.
  • RCAF, “Portrait of Courage: Alan Arnett McLeod, VC” (2017).

Memory and Valour is available wherever you listen to podcasts.

Fire on the Western Front: Flamethrowers, Trench Warfare, and the Canadian Experience

On July 30th, 1915, at a ruined château in Belgium called Hooge, the German Army deployed a weapon that had never been seen on the Western Front. Within minutes, a British battalion broke. Not from shells or gas; from fire.

In Episode 27, we trace the full arc of the flamethrower in the First World War: from its terrifying debut at Hooge, through the doctrinal revolution that transformed it from a shock weapon into a precision tool of combined arms warfare, to its central role in the chaos of Passchendaele and the hammer blow of the German Spring Offensive in 1918.

At the heart of this story is the Garde-Reserve-Pionier-Regiment – the specialist assault unit built around Bernhard Reddemann’s vision of what fire could do to a defensive line – and the Canadian Corps, which faced German flamethrower teams in some of the most brutal engagements of the war.

We look at how the CEF learned to fight back, the brutal simplicity of the counter-doctrine they developed, and what it actually took to hold your ground when liquid fire was coming toward you across a Belgian mud crater.

It’s a story about a weapon. But more than that, it’s a story about adaptation: how armies learn, how soldiers function through primal fear, and how even the most terrifying technology eventually meets its ceiling.

Training footage showing a mock “combined stationary and pouncing attack” [“vereinten stehenden und springenden Angriff”] of the Garde-Reserve-Pionier-Regiment (Flammenwerfer). A type of attack that utilized both large emplaced and small portable flamethrowers (Grof and Wex in this instance). The large flamethrowers were fired at the enemy first lines while shock troops armed with portable flamethrowers, rifles, grenades, etc. rushed towards the trenches to roll and mop them up.
Here is footage of Sturmbataillon Nr. 2 training with elements of the Garde-Reserve-Pionier-Regiment at Wasigny in March 1918, in preparation for the Spring offensives.


Primary Sources
• War Diary, 5th Canadian Mounted Rifles, June 2–4, 1916 (Library and Archives Canada)
• Captain J.H. Symonds, message to 5th CMR HQ, June 2, 1916 (as recorded in 5th CMR War Diary)
• War Diary, 4th Canadian Mounted Rifles, January 24, 1916 (Flammenwerfer demonstration record)
Official Histories
• G.W.L. Nicholson, Canadian Expeditionary Force 1914–1919 (Department of National Defence,
1962), Chapter V “The St. Eloi Craters and Mount Sorrel, 1916,” pp. 149–153 — explicit
confirmation of flame projector use against the 1st and 4th CMR on June 2, 1916
• Lord Beaverbrook, Canada in Flanders, Volume II (cited in Nicholson)


Secondary Sources
• Dr. Tim Cook, At the Sharp End: Canadians Fighting the Great War 1914–1916 (2007)
• Dr. Tim Cook, Shock Troops: Canadians Fighting the Great War 1917–1918 (2008)
• Dr. Spencer Jones (ed.), Stemming the Tide: Officers and Leadership in the British Expeditionary
Force 1914 (2013)
• Mark Zuehlke, “Retaking the high ground,” Legion Magazine (June 2021) — independent
confirmation of flame projector use at Mount Sorrel
• Paul Cornish, “Flamethrower,” 1914–1918-Online: International Encyclopedia of the First World
War (Imperial War Museums, 2016) — verified 105 attacks figure
• Thomas Wictor, German Flamethrower Pioneers of World War I (2007)
• Vimy Foundation, Sanctuary Wood and Mont Sorrel
• Canadian Centre for the Great War, “It Was Simply Hell!” (2021)
• Channel 4 Time Team, “The Lost Weapon of the Somme” (2011) — Centre for Battlefield
Archaeology, University of Glasgow (Pollard, Banks, Barton, Banning)
• Imperial War Museum, Hooge after-action record

BIG NEWS!

I’m excited to announce that all 7 of my books are now available through the official Memory and Valour bookstore!

Check out my bookstore at http://www.payhip.com/memoryandvalour


Years of research, storytelling, and remembrance are now gathered in one place; covering the First World War, Canadian history, and the extraordinary people whose stories deserve to be remembered.


This is a huge milestone for me, and I can’t wait to share these works with even more readers.

Keep history alive, because where memory endures valour lives on.

-Samantha L.G. McCrea

MemoryAndValour

#CanadianHistory #WW1 #MilitaryHistory #HistoryAuthor #MemoryandValour

What Canada Took from Our War Dead: The Hidden Story of Bodies, Medicine, and War.

The primary source for today’s podcast episode is Tim Cook’s Lifesavers and Body Snatchers:
Medical Care and the Struggle for Survival in the Great War
, published in 2022 by Penguin
Random House Canada. It won the 2023 Ottawa Book Award and was shortlisted for the
Templer Medal for Best Book. If this episode made you think, go read the book. It’s one of
the most important works of Canadian military history published in this century.


In the First World War, the Canadian Army Medical Corps stood at the fragile boundary between life and death, tasked with saving the wounded under some of the most brutal conditions ever endured.

Stretcher-bearers crossed open ground under fire. Surgeons operated in makeshift hospitals, racing against time, mud, and infection. Thousands of lives were saved through courage, innovation, and sheer determination.

But behind that story lies a more uncomfortable truth.

Drawing on the research of Tim Cook and his work in Lifesavers and Body Snatchers, this episode explores a lesser-known reality of Canada’s medical war, one in which the dead were not always left in peace.

In the pursuit of knowledge, training, and medical advancement, parts of fallen soldiers were collected, preserved, and used for study and display. It was a practice rooted in necessity, but one that raises difficult questions about consent, dignity, and the true cost of progress.

This is not a story of condemnation, but of confrontation.

Because war does not end with death.
And the work of saving lives sometimes came with a price paid by those who could no longer speak for themselves.


Tim Cook, CM, FRSC — Order of Canada, Fellow of the Royal Society of Canada — died on October 25th, 2025. He was 54 years old. He spent his career telling us the truth about our history, including the parts of it that were hard to tell.

We are richer for it.

Follow Memory and Valour for more stories drawn from the letters, lives, and legacies of the First World War.
Because where memory endures, valour lives on.

SHOW NOTES — SOURCES

Lifesavers and Body Snatchers — Tim Cook (Penguin Random House Canada, 2022)
The Current — CBC Radio (September 8, 2022)
CBC News — Tim Cook obituary (October 26, 2025)
The Western Front Association — Tim Cook obituary (November 2025)
Karyn Mulcahy, Global News — Mütter Museum repatriation (March 10, 2026)
Canadian Armed Forces — News release on Mütter Museum repatriation (March 2026)
Tim Cook lecture — Laurier Centre for the Study of Canada (December 19, 2022, YouTube)
“Did Canada Traffic WWI Soldiers’ Body Parts?” — The Agenda with Steve Paikin (November 10, 2022, YouTube)

Warriors Without Rights: Indigenous Soldiers of the CEF

When the First World War erupted in 1914, Canada answered the call without hesitation. But among those who stepped forward were men who, under Canadian law, were not even recognized as citizens.

In this episode of Memory and Valour, we uncover the powerful and often overlooked story of Indigenous men who volunteered to serve in the Canadian Expeditionary Force. Drawn from communities across the country—from the plains of Alberta to the forests of Ontario—these soldiers fought in some of the war’s most brutal battles, including Ypres, Vimy Ridge, and Passchendaele.

They served as snipers, scouts, and front-line infantry. Many displayed extraordinary skill and courage under fire. Many never returned home.

And yet, their service existed within a profound contradiction.

At the time, Indigenous peoples in Canada lived under the restrictions of the Indian Act—denied the right to vote, limited in their freedom of movement, and treated as wards of the state. Despite this, thousands chose to enlist.

This episode does not simplify their reasons. Instead, it confronts the complexity—honouring their courage while examining the injustice that framed their service.

Because this isn’t just a story of war.

It’s a story of loyalty, identity, sacrifice—and a country still learning how to remember.

**This episode includes audio excerpts from Forgotten Warriors (1997), a documentary produced by the National Film Board of Canada. All rights reserved by the NFB. Used for educational and historical commentary purposes.
We gratefully acknowledge the NFB for preserving and sharing these important historical voices.**

Behind Barbed Wire: Canadian POWs and Internment Camps of WWI

On the battlefields of Europe, nearly 4,000 Canadian soldiers were captured and marched into German prison camps. Their diaries describe starvation, forced labour, and the psychological weight of uncertainty. One POW wrote that “one moment we were fighting, the next we were herded like cattle,” while another recalled that “we were not men in that car. We were cargo.” These firsthand accounts illuminate a side of the war often overshadowed by stories of heroism at the front.
But while Canadian soldiers endured captivity overseas, a very different — and far less acknowledged — system of confinement was unfolding at home.

Between 1914 and 1920, Canada operated 24 internment camps that imprisoned more than 8,500 civilians, many of them Ukrainian, German, Serbian, and other immigrants who had committed no crime. Under the sweeping powers of the War Measures Act, they were labelled “enemy aliens,” stripped of rights, and forced into labour that helped build parts of Canada’s national parks and infrastructure. As one internee later wrote, “We were not soldiers, yet we lived behind barbed wire.”
This episode traces both stories — the soldiers captured in battle and the civilians imprisoned by their adopted country — revealing a complex portrait of fear, resilience, injustice, and the human cost of wartime suspicion. From escape attempts and survival strategies to family separations and the long shadows these camps left behind, Episode 19 challenges the way we remember Canada’s role in the Great War.
If you’re drawn to history that goes beyond the battlefield and into the lived experiences of those caught in its wake, this is an episode that stays with you.

Shock Troops: Canada’s Ruthless Reputation in the Great War

By 1918, the Canadian Corps had earned a name across the Western Front: shock troops.

They were sent where the ground was worst. Where the wire was thickest. Where the objective mattered most. British command relied on them. German reports warned about them. After Vimy Ridge, Passchendaele, Amiens, and the Hundred Days, a reputation took hold: that Canadians were ruthless.

But was it myth?
Was it tactical necessity?
Or was it something far more complicated?

Drawing on the scholarship of Dr. Tim Cook and the words of the soldiers themselves, this episode of Memory and Valour examines how that reputation was built, and what it cost.

This is battlefield reality.
This is moral reckoning.
This is Canada at war.

🎙️ Listen now on Spotify, Apple, and Amazon Music (or wherever you get your podcasts).
🌐 Visit www.memoryandvalour.ca for show notes and more.

#MemoryAndValour #CanadianHistory #GreatWar #WW1 #CanadianCorps

The War That Stayed: Shell Shock and Canadians in the First World War

**content warning: this podcast episode deals with difficult subjects: War trauma, shell shock and veteran suicide. Listener discretion is advised.

Shell Shock in the Canadian Expeditionary Force (WWI)
In this episode of Memory and Valour, we explore shell shock within the Canadian Expeditionary Force during the First World War — long before the condition was understood as PTSD.


As trench warfare intensified across France and Belgium, thousands of Canadian soldiers experienced tremors, paralysis, nightmares, memory loss, and emotional collapse. Military authorities debated whether shell shock was caused by exploding artillery, moral weakness, or psychological trauma. Canadian medical officers struggled to treat it effectively, while stigma and misunderstanding often followed men long after they left the front lines.
Drawing on firsthand accounts, Canadian hospital records, and contemporary medical thinking, this episode examines how shell shock was experienced and treated within the CEF — and how those early responses shaped our modern understanding of operational stress injuries.


The wounds were not always visible.
But they were real.


Listen on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, Amazon Music, and iHeartRadio.
Full show notes and sources are available at http://www.memoryandvalour.ca�.

The Timberwolves’ Legacy: Indigenous Contributions in WWI Canada

The 107th Battalion — known as The Timberwolves — was one of the most remarkable and overlooked units in Canada’s First World War history. Made up largely of First Nations soldiers, these men brought extraordinary skill, resilience, and cultural strength to a war that demanded everything from them… and then asked for more.

In this episode, we uncover the story Canada rarely tells: how Indigenous soldiers carved roads through the impossible, built the very infrastructure of the Western Front, and fought with a loyalty that was never fully returned at home. Through history, testimony, and truth, we explore who the Timberwolves were, what they endured, and why their legacy matters now more than ever.

This is the story of courage in the shadows — and the fight to bring it into the light.